Your shopping cart is currently empty. Please choose from one of our categories to start shopping!
Filter by
Price
- $100.00 or less (3)
- $100.01 - $250.00 (12)
- $250.01 - $500.00 (9)
- $500.01 - $2,500.00 (15)
- $2,500.01 or more (5)
Bargain Bin
- No (44)
Denomination
- Copper-Nickel Indian Cent (2)
- Indian Cent (42)
Mint
- S (3)
U.S. Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)
U.S. Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)
1860 Indian Cent PCGS MS64 Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55586
SKU: PSB55586
This original 1860 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Nice color and surfaces. Couple freckles reverse. Certified: PCGS MS64
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $650.00 | $670.00 |
1862 Indian Cent NGC MS65 Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB43979
SKU: PSB43979
This wonderfully original 1862 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Couple tiny planchet flaws or this might be a 67. Certified: NGC MS65
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,085.00 | $1,115.00 |
1862 Indian Cent PCGS MS63 Decent Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56951
SKU: PSB56951
This 1862 Indian Cent has decent eye appeal and strong strike. A few freckles both sides. Certified: PCGS MS63
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $344.00 | $354.00 |
1863 Indian Cent PCGS MS63 Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB51103
SKU: PSB51103
This original 1863 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Couple freckles away from easy 64. Certified: PCGS MS63
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $365.00 | $375.00 |
1864 Copper-Nickel Indian Cent ANACS AU58 Nice Eye Appeal Nice Strike
SKU: PSB55315
SKU: PSB55315
This original 1864 Copper-Nickel Indian Cent has nice eye appeal and nice strike. Great color and surfaces. Certified: ANACS AU58
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $157.00 | $161.00 |
1864 Copper-Nickel Indian Cent PCGS Unc Details Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56786
SKU: PSB56786
This 1864 Copper-Nickel Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Looks straight grade 62/63 to me. Certified: PCGS Unc Details
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $209.00 | $215.00 |
1864 Indian Cent Bronze PCGS MS66+ RD Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56481
SKU: PSB56481
This original 1864 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Absolutely stunning Gem. Certified: PCGS MS66+ RD
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $6,185.00 | $6,365.00 |
1867 Indian Cent PCGS VG10 Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB47360
SKU: PSB47360
This wonderfully original 1867 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. Certified: PCGS VG10
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $73.00 | $75.00 |
1868 Indian Cent NGC MS63 RB Nice Eye Appeal Nice Strike
SKU: PSB49383
SKU: PSB49383
This original 1868 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and nice strike. Lots more Red than Brown. Likely a 64 or 65 if not for the spot on obverse. Certified: NGC MS63 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $443.00 | $455.00 |
1868 Indian Cent NGC MS65 BN Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56730
SKU: PSB56730
This 1868 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Interesting color. Razor sharp. Certified: NGC MS65 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $830.00 | $855.00 |
1868 Indian Cent Rattler Holder CAC Sticker PCGS MS65 RB Superb Eye Appeal
SKU: PSB40167
SKU: PSB40167
This wonderfully original 1868 Indian Cent Rattler Holder has superb eye appeal with fantastic luster and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. Possible upgrade. Certified: PCGS MS65 RB CAC
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,650.00 | $1,700.00 |
1869 Indian Cent NGC MS64 RB Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB57293
SKU: PSB57293
This wonderfully original 1869 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Superb color and surfaces. Neat die clash. Really nice coin! Certified: NGC MS64 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,755.00 | $1,805.00 |
1869 Indian Cent NGC VF35 BN Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB44592
SKU: PSB44592
This wonderfully original 1869 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. Certified: NGC VF35 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $344.00 | $354.00 |
1870 Indian Cent NGC MS64 RD Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55357
SKU: PSB55357
This 1870 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Interesting color and surfaces. Tough to find this nice! Certified: NGC MS64 RD
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,650.00 | $1,700.00 |
1870 Indian Cent PCGS F15 Great Eye Appeal Nice Strike
SKU: PSB57537
SKU: PSB57537
This original 1870 Indian Cent has great eye appeal and nice strike. Great color and surfaces. Chocolate brown. Certified: PCGS F15
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $198.00 | $204.00 |
1870/18-0 Indian Cent DDO FS-101 NGC XF40 BN Superb Eye Appeal
SKU: PSB48914
SKU: PSB48914
This wonderfully original 1870/18-0 Indian Cent DDO has superb eye appeal and nice strike. Gorgeous chocolate brown color and surfaces. Certified: NGC XF40 BN
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $437.00 | $450.00 |
1871 Indian Cent Proof NGC PF66 RB Nice Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB56199
SKU: PSB56199
This original 1871 Indian Cent has nice eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Nice color and surfaces. Tough to find! Certified: NGC PF66 RB
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $2,475.00 | $2,545.00 |
1872 Indian Cent CAC Sticker PCGS MS64 RB Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55142
SKU: PSB55142
This wonderfully original 1872 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces with nice even Red/Brown surfaces. Certified: PCGS MS64 RB CAC
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $2,580.00 | $2,655.00 |
1872 Indian Cent NGC Unc Details Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB55958
SKU: PSB55958
This 1872 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal with nice luster and strong strike. Looks 64/65 reddish. Great value! Certified: NGC Unc Details
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $1,035.00 | $1,065.00 |
1872 Indian Cent PCGS XF40 Superb Eye Appeal Strong Strike
SKU: PSB47361
SKU: PSB47361
This wonderfully original 1872 Indian Cent has superb eye appeal and strong strike. Outstanding color and surfaces. Certified: PCGS XF40
| Check by mail | Credit Card/PayPal |
|---|---|
| $432.00 | $445.00 |
Learn More About U.S. Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)
The Indian Head penny has long been a popular coin among coin collectors due to the historical significance of its era. The 1864-L, 1877, 1908-S, and 1909-S represent some of the most sought-after years by collectors. The Indian Head was the replacement penny for the Flying Eagle, which was only struck from 1856-1858 due to design flaws. Like the Flying Eagle, the Indian Head was designed by James Longacre, a chief engraver of the U.S. Mint. The Indian Head penny features an Indian head that faces to the left wearing a feather bonnet. The coin’s reverse side shows “ONE CENT” with a laurel wreath. The wreath was changed slightly in 1860 to include three arrows and a shield of the United States. According to the U.S. Department of the Treasury, over 1.8 billion Indian Cent pieces were minted. The composition of these coins evolved from 88% copper 12% nickel (1859-1864) to 95% copper 5% tin and zinc (1864-1909).
How much is an Indian Head penny worth? Contact our expert numismatists at 1-800-965-2646.